Navigating Challenging Experiences on Psilocybin: What to Expect, Why They Happen, and How to Handle Them

Psilocybin therapy is gaining recognition for its transformative potential in treating mental health conditions, but it’s essential to understand that the journey can sometimes involve challenging or difficult experiences. These challenging experiences, sometimes referred to as “bad trips,” are often characterized by intense emotions, discomfort, or distressing thoughts. While these moments can be uncomfortable, they’re also valuable, often leading to meaningful breakthroughs when managed with care. This article explores why challenging experiences on psilocybin happen, how to reduce the risk, what to do if they occur, and what studies have found regarding adverse events in psilocybin therapy.

What Is a Challenging Psilocybin Experience?

A challenging experience on psilocybin is a state of heightened distress, discomfort, or negative emotions that can occur during a psychedelic journey. These experiences vary widely, including feelings of paranoia, fear, existential dread, or confronting difficult memories. While unsettling, challenging experiences often stem from heightened emotional awareness that psilocybin can trigger, making previously suppressed thoughts or emotions more accessible. These experiences can be overwhelming, but many participants report valuable insights or emotional release afterward.

Challenging experiences are not uncommon. In fact, in studies of psychedelic therapy, about 30-40% of participants report experiencing discomfort or emotionally intense periods during the session. However, these experiences are not typically seen as harmful when managed correctly, and in therapeutic settings, they can often lead to profound personal insights.

Why Do Challenging Experiences Happen?

Several factors contribute to the likelihood of a challenging experience on psilocybin:

• Dose: Higher doses increase the intensity of the experience and may amplify both positive and challenging effects.
• Set and Setting: A person’s mental state (set) and physical environment (setting) play significant roles in shaping the psychedelic journey. Feelings of stress, anxiety, or an unsafe environment can contribute to distress.
• Emotional and Psychological History: Psilocybin often brings deeply buried emotions or memories to the surface, which can trigger intense emotional processing, particularly for those with trauma or unresolved issues.
• Surrender and Control: A person’s desire to control the experience can also influence their perception. When resisting intense feelings or trying to suppress emotions, the struggle can intensify negative sensations.

While challenging experiences can be difficult, they’re not necessarily a sign of harm. In fact, these moments are often part of the therapeutic process, as facing and processing difficult emotions can promote healing and resilience.

How to Reduce the Risk of a Challenging Experience

Although it’s not possible to eliminate the risk of a challenging experience entirely, some steps can significantly reduce the likelihood and severity:

1. Set Intentions: Before the session, setting a clear intention can help guide the experience, even if unexpected emotions arise. Intentions create a mental anchor, making it easier to navigate intense moments.
2. Prepare Mentally and Emotionally: Engaging in mindfulness practices or therapy beforehand can help individuals feel more mentally prepared. Understanding that intense emotions may arise can foster acceptance.
3. Optimize the Set and Setting: Being in a safe, calm, and comfortable environment with a supportive, trained therapist is essential. Feeling secure allows individuals to be more open to the experience and process emotions without fear.
4. Start with a Lower Dose: Especially for those new to psilocybin, starting with a lower dose can reduce the likelihood of overwhelming experiences, allowing gradual acclimatization to the effects.
5. Surrender to the Experience: Trying to control or resist the journey can heighten negative emotions. Embracing a mindset of curiosity and acceptance, even during intense moments, can help ease the experience and allow difficult emotions to pass.

What to Do If a Challenging Experience Happens

If a challenging experience arises during psilocybin therapy, there are ways to navigate it constructively:

1. Focus on Breathing: Slow, deep breaths can help calm the body and mind, grounding the individual and easing sensations of panic or anxiety.
2. Embrace an Observer’s Mindset: Reminding oneself that the feelings are temporary and that they’re part of a process can reduce the feeling of being overwhelmed. Observing sensations and thoughts without attaching meaning to them can make them feel less intense.
3. Lean on a Supportive Presence: In a therapeutic setting, a trained therapist or guide will often be present. Talking about what you’re experiencing or asking for guidance can provide reassurance and help process emotions more effectively.
4. Use Positive Reminders: Simple phrases like “This will pass” or “I am safe” can help reinforce a sense of security, making it easier to manage distressing feelings.
5. Allow the Emotions to Flow: Fighting against emotions can increase their intensity, while allowing them to emerge naturally can often reduce their power. Many people find that emotions like sadness or anger dissipate more quickly when they’re allowed to be expressed.

Studies on Challenging Experiences and Adverse Events in Psilocybin Therapy

Studies on psilocybin therapy have shown that while challenging experiences are common, severe adverse events are rare, particularly in controlled, therapeutic settings. The following findings provide insights into the nature of challenging experiences and the role they play in the therapeutic process.

1. Johns Hopkins Study on Mystical and Challenging Experiences

In a well-known 2006 study, Johns Hopkins University researchers examined the effects of psilocybin on 36 participants. While about 30% reported experiencing some degree of fear or paranoia, none experienced lasting negative effects. The study concluded that while challenging experiences were common, they often contributed positively to the overall therapeutic outcome. Participants frequently described a sense of personal growth and insights gained from facing their fears (Griffiths et al., 2006).

2. Survey of Adverse Events in Psilocybin Therapy

A large-scale survey conducted in 2016 investigated adverse effects in recreational and therapeutic psilocybin use. The survey found that challenging experiences were relatively common, with about 39% of participants reporting some distress during the experience. However, when the sessions were guided by trained facilitators, distress was typically resolved without long-term effects. Most participants reported that, despite the difficulty, these experiences contributed to self-understanding and healing (Carbonaro et al., 2016).

3. Psilocybin Therapy for Depression at Imperial College London

A study conducted at Imperial College London investigated psilocybin therapy for treatment-resistant depression. Many participants reported experiencing intense emotional catharsis, confronting memories and emotions they had avoided for years. Although some described these moments as challenging, the study showed that facing difficult emotions led to a significant reduction in depressive symptoms. Almost all participants reported feeling more resilient and better equipped to handle emotions after the session (Carhart-Harris et al., 2018).

4. NYU Langone Health Study on Psilocybin and End-of-Life Anxiety

In a study focused on end-of-life anxiety, NYU Langone Health researchers found that participants with terminal illness often experienced challenging emotions during psilocybin therapy, including grief and existential dread. However, these moments allowed participants to process emotions they had suppressed, leading to increased acceptance and reduced fear of death. Many participants reported that the therapy provided a sense of closure, peace, and improved quality of life in their remaining days (NYU Langone Health, 2016).

The Therapeutic Role of Challenging Experiences

Research on psilocybin therapy shows that challenging experiences, while intense, are often central to the therapeutic process. Facing unresolved emotions or fears can promote personal growth, and integrating these experiences can lead to lasting psychological benefits. In fact, some therapists view challenging experiences as an opportunity to address issues that traditional therapies may struggle to reach.

Studies suggest that individuals who experience challenging sessions are more likely to report long-term positive changes. For many, navigating these emotions fosters resilience and acceptance, equipping them with tools to handle life’s stresses and uncertainties.

Conclusion

Challenging experiences on psilocybin can be intense, but they’re not necessarily negative. In therapeutic settings, these moments provide an opportunity for personal growth and healing, allowing individuals to confront deep-seated fears, anxieties, or past traumas. By preparing mentally, choosing a supportive setting, and embracing acceptance, it’s possible to navigate these experiences constructively. Supported by an experienced therapist and backed by research, challenging psilocybin experiences can be transformed into valuable insights and emotional breakthroughs that contribute to mental health and well-being.

Sources:

1. Griffiths, R.R., et al. (2006). "Psilocybin can occasion mystical-type experiences having substantial and sustained personal meaning and spiritual significance." Johns Hopkins University.
2. Carbonaro, T.M., et al. (2016). "Survey of challenging experiences associated with psilocybin mushrooms: Acute and enduring positive and negative consequences." Journal of Psychopharmacology.
3. Carhart-Harris, R., et al. (2018). "Psilocybin with psychological support for treatment-resistant depression: six-month follow-up." Imperial College London.
4. NYU Langone Health (2016). "Psilocybin Treatment for Anxiety and Depression in Cancer Patients: A Randomized Controlled Trial." NYU Langone Health.

© 2024 Steve Elfrink. All rights reserved.